User talk:Minatte1

Welcome

Welcome to PhantomWiki! It is nice to have another contributor. Karl MAN 21:40, 18 February 2011 (CET)

If you change informations about Fratelli Spada stories based on [1], you must know there is wrong informations about that. I compared first pages of original stories with Swedish version and first story is same, but in second story missing first panel from original (splash page). Delboj4 18:16, 22 February 2011 (CET)

OK, I'm sorry for the wrong information. --Minatte1 18:23, 22 February 2011 (CET)

One page stories in Fantomen

If "Fantomens goda märke" from Fantomen 19/1972 (and in other similiar cases) is article, than it should be separate. Delboj4 17:50, 14 March 2011 (CET)

"Fantomens goda märke" is a one page short Phantom comic. In the early 70's there were some one or two page Phantom comics in Fantomen. Is it a good idea to mention these short comics separate or mention that it is a one page story? --Minatte1 18:01, 14 March 2011 (CET)

Are those pages http://www.schapter.org/wiki/The_Phantom_Legends? Delboj4 18:08, 14 March 2011 (CET)

Even though I don't have the specific issue, I have some issues with these "stories", and I see no reason why there should be two different versions produced in the 1970's, it must be the same. I think that those "stories" also appeared in Mustanaamio. Karl MAN 18:19, 14 March 2011 (CET)

No, The Phantom Legends start in Fantomen 20/1972 and run to Fantomen 19/1973. But there are some earlier one page stories in Fantomen: In Fantomen 20/1970 (2 one page stories), 21 and 25/1970, in Fantomen 11 (2 page story), 13 and 20/1971 and in Fantomen 4, 5, 19 and 21/1972. 2 of these stories is [2] and [3] --Minatte1 18:30, 14 March 2011 (CET)

Could you scan or make photos of those pages and send to me via e-mail markodav2003 (a) yahoo.com? Delboj4 18:34, 14 March 2011 (CET)

OK, I try to do it later this week. --Minatte1 18:38, 14 March 2011 (CET)

Thanks. Maybe than I'll know something more about that, but I am not sure. Delboj4 21:15, 14 March 2011 (CET)

• Fantomen 20/1970 (2 one page stories) - collage from different newspaper stories, "Visste du detta om Fantomen?" is also published in Suuri sarjakirja. Some of panels from "Klassiska ögonblick i Fantomen-historien" are included in articles in Mustanaamio 1/1966 and 2/1966 as separate pictures. How categorize this?
• Fantomen 21/1970 is "Rings" by Bill Harris, and Bill Lignante.
• Fantomen 25/1970 (one page story) - collage from different newspaper stories, also published in Miten kaikki alkoi (but in color, unlike Swedish version). How categorize this?
• Fantomen 11/1971 - two pages excerpt from "The Phantom Chronicles" by Bill Lignante.
• Fantomen 20/1971 - collage from different newspaper stories, also published in Suuri sarjakirja. How categorize this?
• Fantomen 5/1972 - I am not completely sure, but it's probably also collage from different newspaper stories. In this case, some panels could be made in Sweden.
• Fantomen 19/1972 - first page from "Tale of the Good Mark", but rest of that story has new title in same issue. Unlike Fantomen issues, in Finland first page was published in Mustanaamio 5/1973, but rest of story in 14/1973 with the same title.
• Fantomen 21/1972 - one page from "Yes", also published in Mustanaamio 6/1973. Delboj4 11:02, 17 March 2011 (CET)

OK, very good work! I think the one page stories in Fantomen 20/1970, 25/1970 and 20/1971 could be categorized as articles. Maybe that also applies for the page in Fantomen 5/1972. The page in Fantomen 5/1972, is like a classic introduction page for a new story, but it also seems to be a collage. The three "Visste du detta om Fantomen" one page stories from Fantomen 20/1970, 25/1970 and 20/1971 have also been published in Stora Fantomenboken, the one from Fantomen 25/1970 in color. --Minatte1 18:49, 17 March 2011 (CET)

Or maybe categorize them as Illustrated articles? Delboj4 13:52, 18 March 2011 (CET)

You are right, I change to that. --Minatte1 18:11, 18 March 2011 (CET)

About "Fantomenhistoria i bild 1536-1973" from Fantomen 20/1973, is that something like "1492-1975: Glimtar ur en ätts historia" from Stora jubileumsboken? Delboj4 12:15, 20 March 2011 (CET)

Yes, I think so. Unfortunately I don't have the supplement from Fantomen 20/1973. But I believe that "1492-1975: Glimtar ur en ätts historia" from Stora jubileumsboken can be based on "Fantomenhistoria i bild 1536-1973". --Minatte1 12:31, 20 March 2011 (CET)

OK, I'll try find more informations. Delboj4 12:34, 20 March 2011 (CET)

There are some similar one-page informations in Fantomen 13/1999 and the following 20 or so issues (I don't remember the exact number). These pages started to appear with the new look of Fantomen that began in 13/1999 and was always part of the editorial pages. Since they weren't any real stories, they do not appear in the articles, but perhaps they should? If anyone have both these issues and 20/72 - 19/73, they could compare and see if it is the same, or if it actually is a new thing that was made (and colorized). I also would like to point out that the artwork used, mainly seems to be from the 1960's, so there is a good chance that they are the same. Karl MAN 18:05, 23 March 2011 (CET)

Yes, the 15/1993 (called Chapter 3) is a colorized version of 20/1972 (called Chapter 1). --MiGi 18:48, 23 March 2011 (CET)

Yes, the Phantom Legends pages from 1999-2000 are very much the same as the pages from 1972-1973. 17 of the 26 original pages were reprinted and colorized. I know that some pages were partially changed in case of changes in the Phantom's world since the 70's. For example is the page about President Luaga in Fantomen 26/1999 updated compared to the page in Fantomen 11/1973 --Minatte1 20:08, 23 March 2011 (CET)